top of page

How to Keep Your Tenants Happy and Retain Long-Term Renters

  • Writer: XL Props
    XL Props
  • Dec 19, 2024
  • 3 min read

Finding great tenants is hard. Keeping them? That’s even harder. But the effort pays off. Happy tenants are more likely to renew leases, treat your property well, and even recommend you to others. Tenant retention not only saves time but also cuts down on the costs associated with turnover—like marketing, cleaning, and repairs.


So, how do you create an environment where tenants feel valued and want to stick around? Here are actionable tips to foster long-term tenant relationships.


"For Rent" sign on a window with phone number 682-7891. Background shows blurred lights and a twilight sky, creating a moody atmosphere.
Happy tenants are actually an "investment" on your investment. Keeping turnover costs low keep your property in the green!

1. Be Responsive and Proactive

Why it matters: Nobody likes to feel ignored—especially when their home is on the line. Responding promptly to tenant concerns shows you care.

How to implement it:

  • Fast response times: Reply to maintenance requests within 24 hours and resolve urgent issues as quickly as possible.

  • Preventive maintenance: Regularly inspect HVAC systems, plumbing, and appliances to catch problems before tenants notice them.

  • Open communication: Use tools like email or tenant portals to maintain ongoing communication about upcoming inspections or repairs.


2. Offer Clear and Fair Lease Agreements

Why it matters: Confusion leads to frustration. A straightforward lease agreement helps tenants feel secure and establishes trust.

How to implement it:

  • Avoid legal jargon—make lease terms easy to understand.

  • Clearly outline policies on rent, repairs, and renewals.

  • Be consistent: Apply rules equally to all tenants to maintain fairness.


3. Maintain the Property in Top Condition

Why it matters: A well-maintained property isn’t just appealing—it signals that you respect your tenants.

How to implement it:

  • Regularly inspect and refresh communal areas like hallways and laundry rooms.

  • Keep landscaping neat and seasonal.

  • Upgrade appliances or features when they start to show wear. A new fridge or modern fixtures can make a big impression.


4. Respect Their Privacy

Why it matters: While it’s your property, it’s their home. Respecting boundaries builds goodwill.

How to implement it:

  • Give at least 24-48 hours’ notice before entering the property, except in emergencies.

  • Use digital tools to schedule appointments, so tenants know exactly when to expect you.


5. Foster a Sense of Community

Why it matters: People want to live in a space where they feel a sense of belonging.

How to implement it:

  • Organize events like holiday gatherings or community yard sales.

  • Create shared spaces like outdoor seating areas or a small garden.

  • Use a tenant newsletter to share updates and encourage community engagement.


6. Be Flexible When Possible

Why it matters: Life happens. Offering some leeway can turn a tense situation into a moment of loyalty.

How to implement it:

  • Offer grace periods for late rent payments under exceptional circumstances.

  • Allow minor customization of units (like painting walls) to help tenants feel at home.

  • Be open to negotiating lease renewals based on tenant needs.


7. Reward Loyalty

Why it matters: Small gestures can have a big impact on tenant satisfaction.

How to implement it:

  • Offer renewal incentives like rent discounts or small upgrades.

  • Send holiday or birthday cards to personalize your relationship.

  • Provide a welcome gift at the start of each lease, such as a gift card or household essentials.


8. Keep Rent Increases Reasonable

Why it matters: Sudden, steep rent hikes can drive even the happiest tenants away.

How to implement it:

  • Base increases on market trends, not just your expenses.

  • Give tenants plenty of notice about rent adjustments.

  • Highlight the value they’re getting (e.g., upgraded amenities or utilities included).


9. Listen to Feedback

Why it matters: Tenants who feel heard are more likely to stay long-term.

How to implement it:

  • Send out periodic surveys to gauge satisfaction and identify areas for improvement.

  • Act on feedback where possible, and communicate updates to tenants.

  • Create an open-door policy for suggestions or complaints.


10. Provide Convenient Payment Options

Why it matters: Making rent payments easy shows you value your tenants’ time.

How to implement it:

  • Use online payment systems that accept various methods, like credit cards or ACH transfers.

  • Set up automated reminders to reduce missed payments.


Final Thoughts

Keeping tenants happy isn’t rocket science—it’s about building trust, showing respect, and creating a comfortable living environment. While some investments, like property upgrades or events, may cost a bit upfront, the long-term rewards of tenant retention far outweigh the expenses.


At XL Property & Contracting, we know that happy tenants lead to thriving investments. If you’re a property owner looking to maximize your rental income and minimize headaches, reach out to us. Our property management expertise will help you attract and retain the best tenants, creating value for years to come.


 
 
 

Comments


Describe what work or service you need done, and we will contact you as soon as possible to arrange a time to meet

Tiny XL Property & Contracting logo

WI Dwelling Contractor License Number: 1352562

© 2025 by XL Property and Contracting LLC

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

CONTACT

Phone: 1-877-277-6817

Email: xl@xlprop.com

5722 W North Ave

Milwaukee WI, 53208

OFFICE HOURS

Mon - Fri: 9am - 6pm

​​Saturday: 9am - 12pm

​Sunday: Closed

By Appointment

RESOURCES

Blog

Join Our Newsletter

Privacy and Terms

bottom of page